Ads for OTC switches skip risk info, study finds

Share this article:
Ads for OTC switches skip risk info, study finds
Ads for OTC switches skip risk info, study finds

A study of advertising for drugs that have made the switch from prescription to over-the-counter status found that the presentation of risk information plummeted once the products advertised escaped the purview of the FDA.

The study, which was reported in the Journal of the American Medical Association, looked at print and broadcast ads—133 in all—for four products in the 24 months before and six months after they went OTC. Those products were Schering-Plough's Claritin (loratidine, which went OTC in 2002); AstraZeneca's Prilosec (omeprazole, OTC as of 2004); GSK's Alli (orlistat, OTC in 2007); and McNeil's Zyrtec (cetirizine, 2008). The study  found that while the presentation of the products' benefits ticked up a notch after the switch, going from 83% to 97%, presentation of their potential harms plummeted, going from  70% to just 11%.

“With the exception of print advertisements for orlistat, no post-switch advertisements mentioned contra-indications or adverse effects,” wrote the study's authors. After the switch to OTC, just half of ads mentioned the generic name of the drug, compared to nearly all for the prescription-only period.

The study's authors noted that after an OTC switch, regulatory authority over the advertising of a drug switches from FDA to the FTC, which “holds drug advertisements to the same standards as any consumer product: it applies a ‘reasonable consumer' standard of truthfulness and non-deception that does not require any balancing of potential benefits and harms.”

FDA advertising standards, they argued, are inconsistently enforced and frequently inadequate, but “DTCA after OTC switch presents even less information for making an informed decision, at a time when consumers must have more knowledge of whether medications' potential benefits are worth their risks and costs. Pharmaceuticals do not lose their capacity of harm after moving from behind the pharmacist's counter to in front of it; misuse of OTC drugs remains a major cause of emergency department visits, hospitalization and death.”

Four of the study's authors were at Brigham and Women's Hospital, while a fifth researcher works for CVS Caremark. The study's lead author, Dr. Jeremy Greene, is now at Johns Hopkins University.
Share this article:
close

Next Article in Features

Email Newsletters

More in Features

Leadership Exchange: How Do We Get Beyond the Pill?

Leadership Exchange: How Do We Get Beyond the ...

As its focus moves from manufacturing to service, pharma needs to partner with healthcare neophytes as well as established players. James Chase asks six experts to assess the risks and ...

FDA and off-label uses: a balancing act

FDA and off-label uses: a balancing act

FDA's current re-examination of its off-label promotion policies in light of the First Amendment is a delicate balancing act between its rock-solid traditional enforcement posture and a diverse new electronic ...

Read the complete August 2014 Digital Edition

Read the complete August 2014 Digital Edition

Click the above link to access the complete Digital Edition of the August 2014 issue of MM&M, with all text, charts and pictures.