Antidote: New diet drugs

Share this article:
Marc Siegel, MD
Marc Siegel, MD

It may not be news to you, but the US has an obesity problem. A study by Duke researchers in the American Journal of Preventive Medicine says that 42% of Americans may be obese by 2030, leading to $550 billion in extra costs to our health care system.

For patients who can't or won't exercise, or those who can't or won't eat right, I have to find other solutions—which include weight loss drugs.

My options are limited. Meridia, an appetite suppressant, was removed from the market in 2010 because of associated risks of heart disease and stroke. Fen-phen was famously removed from the market in 1997 because of risks of heart valve problems and increased pressure in the blood vessels of the lungs.

The FDA, wary of another fen-phen disaster, hasn't approved a weight loss drug since xenical in 1999. Xenical interferes with the absorption of fats in the bowel, causing unpleasant side effects, so it is of limited use.

Now along come Qnexa and Lorcaserin, which have just been approved by a panel advising the FDA, which means almost certain FDA approval.  But I find both drugs problematic, and would be reluctant to prescribe them at least initially.

Qnexa includes topiramate, a seizure drug which can cause confusion and lethargy. Lorcaserin, which promotes a feeling of satiety, has been less successful in terms of the goal of weight loss, and needs further study in terms of risks of heart disease or tumors.

Both drugs will likely be approved, but this physician will wait a long while before prescribing them.

Marc Siegel, MD, is an internist and professor of medicine at New York University and the author of False Alarm: The Truth About the Epidemic of Fear
Share this article:

Email Newsletters

More in Features

Headliner: Proteus CEO takes an original path

Headliner: Proteus CEO takes an original path

Andrew Thompson, CEO, Proteus Digital Health

Leadership Exchange: How Do We Get Beyond the Pill?

Leadership Exchange: How Do We Get Beyond the ...

As its focus moves from manufacturing to service, pharma needs to partner with healthcare neophytes as well as established players. James Chase asks six experts to assess the risks and ...

FDA and off-label uses: a balancing act

FDA and off-label uses: a balancing act

FDA's current re-examination of its off-label promotion policies in light of the First Amendment is a delicate balancing act between its rock-solid traditional enforcement posture and a diverse new electronic ...