As I see it

Share this article:
The FDA's formal public examination of a third class of drugs for the US, between Rx and OTC, sets the stage for a bruising battle between an industry that has always fought the concept and the pharmacy profession which has yearned for it as a professional enhancement long established elsewhere.

In October, the FDA announced it was advancing a proposal to create the new class as a “behind-the-counter (BTC)” category in which products could be sold only after “intervention” by a pharmacist. It scheduled a public meeting in November to receive comments on the idea.
The nonprescription drug industry's Consumer Health Products Association (CHPA) and an unnatural ally, the director of the Public Citizen Health Research Group, Sidney M. Wolfe, counseled against it. CHPA extolled the “impressive safety record” of the existing two-class system, while Wolfe worried about “many unanswered questions,” including whether pharmacists have the training and the time to explain the drugs and side effects, and whether manufacturers would use the category to avoid regulation.

What's giving impetus to the FDA now is the embarrassment it suffered when making the emergency contraceptive Plan B available on a limited, behind-the-counter basis last year, and then again this year with the weight-loss drug orlistat. In both cases, the FDA had to stage-manage an ad hoc, extra-legal and “voluntary” marketing restriction by the manufacturers involved.
Over the years, US pharmacists have pushed for it as a professional enhancement, only to be driven back each time by the industry, aided by abuses of the privileged reported in foreign pharmacies.

Still, the FDA needs more flexibility than it now has.

Dickinson is editor of Dickinson's FDA Webview (

Share this article:
You must be a registered member of MMM to post a comment.

Next Article in As I See It

Email Newsletters

MM&M Future Leaders

Register now

Early bird $1,950 before 31 October 2014

*Group discounts available on request 


Patient access to pharmaceuticals is a tale of two worlds—affordability has improved for the majority, while the minority is hampered by cost, distribution and red tape. To provide marketers with a well-rounded perspective, MM&M presents this e-book chock full of key insights. Click here to access it.

More in As I See It

As I See It: Patient Centricity

As I See It: Patient Centricity

A patient who is diagnosed earlier and receives the most efficacious treatment is the least expensive

As I See It: FDA's social-media moves

As I See It: FDA's social-media moves

FDA has insisted that its antique regulations can address every new promotional challenge

As I See It: FDA and marketing materials

As I See It: FDA and marketing materials

The more clarity that FDA provides, the more confident companies can be in their medical communications