Vermont data ban struck down in federal court

A federal appeals court reversed a district court ruling that limited the use of prescriber-identifiable data in Vermont, signaling a victory for plaintiffs IMS Health, SDI and Wolters Kluwer Health, and setting up a possible Supreme Court showdown.
Vermont's data ban, which made it illegal to gather and sell information about a physician's prescribing habits without his or her consent, was overturned in part because it “does not directly advance the substantial state interests asserted by Vermont,” wrote District Judge John Koeltl, in the ruling.
These include “protecting the public health,” “protecting the privacy of prescriber and prescribing information,” and “ensuring [healthcare] costs are contained.
The Vermont ruling, decided by the 2nd US Circuit Court of Appeals, runs counter to a 1st US Circuit Court of Appeals decision in 2008, which examined a similar data ban in New Hampshire. The Supreme Court declined to hear plaintiff arguments about the NH data ban.
Based on the variety of court rulings in New Hampshire, Maine, and Vermont—the only three states that have passed laws banning prescriber data—the jury is still out on whether prescriber data qualifies as protected commercial speech under the First Amendment, without caveat.
“We have a split between the 1st and 2nd Circuits now, perhaps increasing the chances of a review by the US Supreme Court of these fundamental First Amendment issues,” said Cathy Betz, VP, government affairs at Wolters Kluwer Health.
You must be a registered member of MMM to post a comment.
close

Next Article in Features

Email Newsletters


As US pharma continued its quest for a Grand Prix at the Lions Health international festival of creativity, MM&M went on location to Cannes, France. Missed our coverage from June? Now, we're giving you an opportunity to catch up on some of what you missed. Download our e-book on the two-day festival, recapping the event, rounding up the best of the speakers, offering perspective and listing all of the winners. Click here to download.


The most recent MM&M Skill Sets Live event surveyed a range of issues relating to one of the hottest promotional spaces in healthcare. Speakers and panelists at the morning-long session, including promotional- and multichannel-minded executives from GSK, Epocrates, Treato and Montefiore Medical Center, weighed in on topics designed to help marketers demystify the challenges associated with non-personal promotion. Click here.