Vermont court upholds commercial data ban

Share this article:

A federal court in Vermont quashed the efforts of several marketing research firms to overturn a statewide ban that restricts the use of prescriber-identifiable (PI) data. 


The ban, which prohibits companies from "selling or using PI data for marketing or promoting prescription drugs unless the prescriber consents [by opting-in]," is scheduled to become effective July 1, 2009.


Cathy Betz, VP, government affairs at Wolters Kluwer Health, said the company is "evaluating its legal options, which may include an appeal of Judge Murtha's decision with the Second Circuit Court of Appeals, as well as seek an injunction against the law's implementation...pending the appeal review."


Unlike IMS Health vs. Ayotte in New Hampshire, the Vermont decision does view PI data as protected commercial speech. However, the court upheld the "opt-in" provision—the meat of the ban—citing an allowance for restriction if it a) supports a substantial government interest; b) directly advances the asserted interest; and c) is not more extensive than is necessary to serve that interest.


"The law is sustainable on cost containment and public health interests, which are substantial," the court decided. 


Betz disputed the court's suggestion that the use of PI data leads to higher costs. 


"There is no evidence—empirical or otherwise—that the specific use of PI information for commercial purposes increases healthcare costs," said Betz. "Likewise, assertions that these data are used to influence physicians to prescribe only more expensive brand name drugs are unfounded," she said. 


Share this article:
close

Next Article in Features

Email Newsletters

More in Features

FDA and off-label uses: a balancing act

FDA and off-label uses: a balancing act

FDA's current re-examination of its off-label promotion policies in light of the First Amendment is a delicate balancing act between its rock-solid traditional enforcement posture and a diverse new electronic ...

Read the complete August 2014 Digital Edition

Read the complete August 2014 Digital Edition

Click the above link to access the complete Digital Edition of the August 2014 issue of MM&M, with all text, charts and pictures.