Vioxx judge declares mistrial

Share this article:
The judge in the first federal lawsuit against Merck's Vioxx has declared a mistrial, according to published reports.
The ruling came this morning after jurors remained deadlocked following 18 hours of deliberations over three days last week.
According to published reports, the jury resumed what was to be its fourth day of deliberations today, but within about 20 minutes, U.S. District Judge Eldon Fallon summoned the jurors and reminded them they had agreed to reach a verdict in a "reasonable time."
"It has now been a reasonable time. We cannot get a verdict," Fallon reportedly said, declaring a mistrial. Federal litigation requires a unanimous verdict.
The panel was reported to be at odds over whether Merck was liable in Richard "Dicky" Irvin's 2001 death and whether the company failed to issue safety warnings that the drug could have serious cardiovascular repercussions.
This latest outcome leaves Merck with a 1-and-1 record in state trials and an undecided in the first of four federal trials overseen by Fallon. The company is up against about 7,000 pending state and federal lawsuits and its liability has been estimated at up to $50 billion.
Share this article:

Email Newsletters

More in Business Briefs

AstraZeneca takes on pediatricians

The American Academy of Pediatricians says an AstraZeneca drug for preemies should be used less often, and the drugmaker is fighting back with an ad campaign that says the new guidelines put too many at risk.

UK generic use soared in 2013

Generics made up almost 75% of prescriptions in the United Kingdom last year.

GSK refutes consumer spin-off rumor

The company refutes a Financial Times rumor that one was happening soonish.