Federal preemption fails in award against Wyeth products

Share this article:
Federal preemption arguments failed in October to prevent a Nevada jury from awarding three women $134.5 million in their suit against Wyeth over its hormone replacement products Premarin and Prempro that they alleged caused their breast cancer. Later, the presiding judge slashed $100 million from the award as improperly punitive and ordered the jury to reconsider it.

The award was seen as daunting for Wyeth as it defends more than 5,000 similar lawsuits across the country. A penalty phase of the trial continues, which could lead to more monetary damages.
Preemption arguments were first raised in Wyeth's 2004 answer to the plaintiffs' complaint. The company said plaintiffs' claims that its products were unsafe are barred by the doctrine of preemption and the Supremacy Clause of the Constitution.

“Any claim for injunctive relief is preempted or barred by federal law because such a claim would impede, frustrate and burden the effectiveness of federal law regulating the field of prescription drugs; require Wyeth to meet conflicting obligations under federal and state law; and constitute an invalid burden on interstate commerce…,” it said.

Share this article:
You must be a registered member of MMM to post a comment.
close

Next Article in Features

Email Newsletters

More in Features

Read the complete September 2014 Digital Edition

Read the complete September 2014 Digital Edition

Click the above link to access the complete Digital Edition of the August 2014 issue of MM&M, with all text, charts and pictures.

Medical marketing needs mainstream Mad Men

Medical marketing needs mainstream Mad Men

Agencies must generate emotional resonance with the target audience, not unlike Apple, Pepsi or Nike

Are discounts cutting out co-pays?

GSK's decision to cut Advair's price spurred some PBMs to put it back on formulary. Will drugmaker discounts diminish the need for loyalty programs? How can these programs stay relevant beyond giving co-pay assistance?